資源描述:
《惲鐵樵與陸淵雷學(xué)術(shù)觀點比較》由會員上傳分享,免費在線閱讀,更多相關(guān)內(nèi)容在學(xué)術(shù)論文-天天文庫。
1、·206中華醫(yī)史雜志2010年7月第4O卷第4期ChinJMedHiJuO,,盟!.論著惲鐵樵與陸淵雷學(xué)術(shù)觀點比較楊枝青畢麗娟楊杏林【摘要】惲鐵樵與陸淵雷皆為棄文業(yè)醫(yī)者,既廣學(xué)博識,又長期涉足中醫(yī)臨床與中醫(yī)教育,二人的醫(yī)事活動都與近代中醫(yī)發(fā)展密切相關(guān)。惲氏年歲稍長,持改進(jìn)中醫(yī)論,在近代率先比較系統(tǒng)地提出中西醫(yī)匯通的學(xué)術(shù)思想。陸氏稍幼,堅持“中醫(yī)科學(xué)化”的觀點,為后期中西醫(yī)匯通派的代表性人物。二人的學(xué)術(shù)思想雖有頗多共同之處,如學(xué)宗仲景,重視傷寒、倡導(dǎo)革新,匯通中西、反對廢醫(yī)等;但是也有不少明顯的差異:如關(guān)于《傷寒論》與《內(nèi)經(jīng)》關(guān)系、溫病學(xué)說、脈學(xué)理論、中醫(yī)病名、日
2、本漢方醫(yī)等方面的認(rèn)識。比較分析其異同,有利于借鑒、繼承二人學(xué)術(shù)思想的優(yōu)秀部分,促進(jìn)當(dāng)代中醫(yī)學(xué)的發(fā)展?!娟P(guān)鍵詞】惲鐵樵;陸淵雷;中西醫(yī)匯通派ComparisonofAcademicViewpointsbetweenYunTie—qiaoandLuYuan—leiYANGZhi—qing,,Li—juan.rANGXing—lin.ShanghaiInstituteofTraditionalChineseMedicinalLiterature,Shanghai,200020,China【Abstract】BothrunTie-qiaoandLuYuan—leiare
3、medicalprofessionalscomingfromtheliteraryfieldwithversatileandin—depthknowledgeandextensiveexperienceinmedicaleducationandclinicalpractice,allcloselyrelatedtomodernTCMdevelopment.Yun,theelder,insistedonreformingTCMandwasearlytoadvocatetheacademicideaofamalgamatingwesternandtraditiona
4、lChinesemedicine;whileLu,theyounger,insistedontheideaof“scientizingTCM’’andwastherepresentativeofamalgamatingwesternandtraditionalChinesemedicineinthelaterstage.Theysharedmanycommonviewpoints,inclu—dingveneratingZhangZhongjing,stressingexogenouscoldpathogens,advocatingreformationanda
5、malga—mationofwesternmedicineandTCMandobjectingtotheabolishmentofTCM.However,thereweredis-erepaneiesbetweenthem,includingtherelationshipbetweentheInnerCanonandtheEssayonExogenousColdDiseases,warmdiseasetheory,pulsetheory,titlesofTCMdiseasesandJapaneseKampomedicine.Acomparisonoftheman
6、dnotingtheirvaluablecontributionswillbebeneficialforthepromotionofthedevel-opmentofTCM.【Keywords】YunTie—qiao;LuYuan-lei;SchoolofamalgamatingwesternandtraditionalChi—nesemedicine惲鐵樵(1878—1935),名樹鈺,江蘇武進(jìn)人,近點為號召,陸淵雷得知后,便欣然給惲氏寫信,要求代著名中西醫(yī)匯通大師,在民國早期倡導(dǎo)改進(jìn)中醫(yī),拜他為師,并奉上學(xué)費。接到信后惲氏即派門人持被譽為“近代中醫(yī)界精通舊學(xué)
7、,獨具只眼,又受過較親筆信退還學(xué)費,說陸淵雷才學(xué)出眾,不必以師生相系統(tǒng)近代科學(xué)訓(xùn)練的第一人”。稱。不過陸淵雷在《傷寒論今釋·敘例》中仍謙稱:陸淵雷(1894—1955),名彭年,江蘇川沙(今上“余少壯之年,棄儒學(xué)醫(yī),受《傷寒論》于武進(jìn)惲鐵樵海市浦東新區(qū))人,近代以持“中醫(yī)科學(xué)化”觀點而先生?!甭劽?。惲鐵樵、陸淵雷雖具師徒名份,但其學(xué)術(shù)觀點有1925年惲鐵樵為弘揚中醫(yī),改進(jìn)中醫(yī),在上海同有異,各具特色,值得深入比較研究。創(chuàng)辦“中國通函教授學(xué)社”,此即后世通稱的“鐵樵1.相近之處函授中醫(yī)學(xué)?!薄T撔R灾嗅t(yī)理論結(jié)合現(xiàn)代醫(yī)學(xué)觀1.1學(xué)宗仲景重視傷寒DOI:10.3760
8、/cma.j.issn.